Sunday, October 28, 2012

Bogota and Curitiba Revolutionizing City Life


Many cities in our world have been changing the way in which people live. These urban areas have revolutionized the way a multitude of people live with one another. Curitiba and Bogota are two cities that have modified “city life” in recent years. Despite their dissimilarities, Curitiba and Bogota are prime examples of urban areas where politicians and citizens were able to come up with sustainable solutions to the issues of a city.  
At first, one might think that other than being on the 
same continent, the cities of Curitiba and Bogota have nothing in common. Upon further investigation, one is able to realize that these two cities actually have some similarities. In the last 50 years both of these cities experienced massive population growth. “In the 1960s, the population growth in Curitiba reached the highest growth rate of the country, an average of over 5% per year” (Carballo 2010). As stated in one of the videos, Bogota faced similar growths in its population as well. As a result of the drastic rise in the number of people living in these metropolises, the cities were beginning to face other problems that in turn hindered the landscape, infrastructure, health, and welfare of the area and its people.
As multitudes of people were migrating to Curitiba, more and more automobiles were being found on the streets. In the 1970’s, when the now-renowned planner Jaime Lerner became mayor, he was challenged with an issue. Developers in the city had planned to expand the road network in Curitiba, thus causing the city to be less “pedestrian friendly.” Bogota had also been experiencing issues with cars during its rise in population. When Enrique Penalosa was mayor he encountered a problem where the Japanese International Cooperation Agency proposed that seven elevated highways be built within Bogota. During the 20th century, these cities in South America were beginning to encounter the phenomena of the luxuries of automotive transit. Sadly, the consequences of these automobiles were altering the face of the cities in negative ways.
One of the biggest problems of Curitiba and Bogota is the slums that surround the periphery of the urban areas. These slums are full of poor people that live wretched lives. More often than not, these individuals resort to violence and crime to survive. Both mayors in these cities recognized this as a problem. Instead of disowning these people, they believed that by improving the lives of the poor they could quite possibly also enhance the city life for all citizens. For example, in Curitiba Lerner put forward a program where slum dwellers were able to receive food in exchange for cleaning/collecting the garbage. Penalosa tried to improve the lives of the poor in Bogota differently. He improved their lives by enhancing the facilities that many citizens used for recreation. The two progressive mayors in Bogota and Curitiba realized that the problems in the slums needed to be fixed, and they did their best to improve the conditions for all within their cities.
Yet, despite facing similar issues, the two cities of Bogota and Curitiba are different from one another in several ways. Even though both countries are found in South America, these two cities are found in countries that have distinct cultures. Curitiba is found in Brazil, whose way of life is based mostly on Portuguese culture while the lifestyles of the people in Bogota, which is found in Colombia, is influenced by Spanish culture. Another difference is the importance of each city in their respected countries. Bogota is the capital city of Colombia, so it is recognized by many as being an epicenter of many things within the country. Sadly, unless they know about its link to urban planning, many people might not know about Curitiba. Unlike Bogota, it is not the capital city of its respected country, Brazil. These two cities are also drastically different in size. In terms of population, both are large cities, but Bogota almost has 7 times as many people living in it than Curitiba. In 2010, there were 7,363,782 people living in the city of Bogota  itself (excluding the larger metropolitan area) while the city of Curitiba had a population of 1,764,540 (City Data 2010).  

Wednesday, October 17, 2012

How is Jefferson Park?: Analyzing My Neighborhood


Known as the “city of neighborhoods,” Chicago is comprised of many communities that are diverse and distinct. Each of these neighborhoods allows Chicago to be the unique metropolis that it is. The neighborhood I live in is Jefferson Park.
            Nicknamed the “Gateway to Chicago,” Jefferson Park is one of the major transportation hubs in the city of the Chicago. The Chicago El rapid transit system, the Metra commuter line, and CTA buses can all be found at the main terminal in the area. All of these modes of transportation can be used to get to the Loop. Most of the residents work either within the Loop or on the outskirts of the Loop. Being an important transportation hub, a majority of the residents commute to work via public transportation. 
           It isn’t a problem to walk around the neighborhood. Although the neighborhood is walkable, Jefferson Park is quite large, so it may take one a while to walk anywhere. Despite this being case, the bus system is quite interconnected, so if the walk to the neighborhood’s stores and shops is too far, one can get there by using public transportation (CTA bus). Most of the main streets in the area are pretty “complete.” These streets have center-turn lanes and bike lanes. Most of these streets are “complete,” but not all of them. I think it would be a great improvement to my neighborhood if more streets in Jefferson Park were “complete.” In my opinion, “complete” streets would benefit all of the parties that use them (pedestrians, bicyclists, and drivers). Although Jefferson Park has a lot of great modes of transit, it does not have a lot of green infrastructure within its boundaries. There is a forest preserve, but it is found on the edge of the neighborhood. Personally, I wish there were a lot more forest preserves like this one and other components of green infrastructure within my neighborhood.
            In my opinion, Jefferson Park has an identifiable center. I think the center of the neighborhood is the area surrounding the transit center (near the intersection of Milwaukee and Lawrence). All of the different modes of transportation converge at this transit center. A lot of restaurants, businesses, and a park (Jefferson Park) surround the transit center, thus people are drawn to go there. Even though, the neighborhood has an identifiable center, I don’t think it has edges that are noticeable. It can be a blur where Jefferson Park begins and ends. As I stated earlier, most of the neighborhood is walkable. For example, I go on strolls all the time in my neighborhood. I enjoy walking around my neighborhood and seeing everything that it has to offer. I usually walk to the main park, Jefferson Park, but there are a lot of smaller parks where people can walk to and just relax (like Dunham Park and Austin-Foster Park). These parks are a few of the spaces in my neighborhood that I consider third places. 
            I would hope that in 50 years my neighborhood of Jefferson Park would be a community that relies less on automobiles. Even though Jefferson Park is a transportation hub, a lot of people still use automobiles to get around. I would hope to see in the future that residents will only use cars for immediate emergencies or extremely long journeys. I would hope this would be the case, but sadly I don’t think it will happen. Most Americans have a strong connection with automotive transit. Due to this fact, it seems to me that it will be a difficult task for Jefferson Park residents to transform the neighborhood to an almost “car-less community.” I think the same would be said of green infrastructure. I would hope more green infrastructure would be developed in the neighborhood, but it seems to me that people don’t have very strong feelings about nature. Hopefully if more people learned about the importance of the foundations of sustainability and how it can benefit us all, then such neighborhoods like mine could become places that compliment urban sustainability. 

Monday, October 8, 2012

A Common Tragedy, The Tragedy of the Commons


The other day I was checking the news on the BBC website. While I was looking at the leading stories of the day, I came across a story about the worst traffic jams in the world (http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-19716687). The article noted several cities around the world to have some of the worst traffic jams. These cities ranged from Jakarta in Indonesia to Kampala in Uganda. Upon reading these accounts of congestion, I was reminded of Hardin’s concept of the “tragedy of the commons.” In other words, I came to realize that this article on congestion was a perfect example of a resource on our planet that is used by many, yet not owned by anyone.
Hardin’s paper “The Tragedy of the Commons” documents the drastic and startling truth about common resources. The paper spells out the tragedy as “the results that come about when a single resource is owned and accessed by everyone, and regulated by no one. Without some type of self-policing, this resource will disappear.” Although it might not seem apparent, the congestion that is found in major cities around the world is a result of the “tragedy of the commons.” The interstates and highways in most, if not all, of these countries is a public good that can be used by anyone with a car. That is, anyone who possesses a vehicle is able to drive onto these transportation systems and travel about. As a result of this fact, these transportation systems get overused. This is not always the case. There are times where the number of automobiles on the interstate system does not have drastic effects on people’s travel times. But as more and more vehicles enter these transportation systems, there is less room for people to move about. With less space for all of the cars on the road, the velocities of the cars will decrease. This increase in the number of vehicles on highways and interstates causes the travel times of vehicles to slow down, which in turn causes congestion.
Space on highway systems can be obtained by anyone with a vehicle. In other words, as stated before, anyone with a car can drive onto these transportation systems. No one really owns the space on the highway systems, so as a result of it being owned by no one yet used by many, the space on highway systems is a resource that gets overused and exploited. But one might ask are there any solutions to this problem? One solution that people propose is for individuals to carpool to work. Advocates to this solution believe that more people should travel to work together. They should carpool because it seems as if there are many cars on the road that are occupied by only one person. If more people began to carpool, then one can argue there will be fewer cars on the road. Another solution that some individuals propose is to stop using automobiles to get around a city. Advocates of this proposition believe it would be in the best interest of everyone to use other modes of transportation. People should either ride their bicycles to work, ride the local commuter rail line, use buses to travel around, or just walk.
            Personally, I believe that the solution about people finding other means of transit is the better solution to the problem. Not only will it fix the “tragedy of the commons” with space on the highways, but it will also lessen other issues. This solution will diminish the amount of greenhouse gases in the atmosphere as well as reduce our dependence on oil. Even though I think this is the better solution, I don’t think it is the solution that will work right away, especially not in the United States. Sadly, most Americans have a strong connection with automotive transit. Due to this fact, it seems to me that it will be a difficult task for Americans to transition to other means of transit. With that said, I think the solution that will work for now would be the proposition for individuals to start carpooling. Hopefully, once people begin to carpool, they will gradually transition to other means of transportation.  

Sunday, September 30, 2012

Automobiles: Not a Necessity in Urban Areas with Compact Development


In the article Growing Cooler, Ewing discusses a sustainable method known as compact development. Such a development enhances a group of communities to focus land uses around a transit station or within a transit corridor. In other words, it is a method in which Americans can reduce the vehicle miles traveled, thus lowering the amount of greenhouse gases in the air. “Better community planning and more compact development will help people live within walking or bicycling distance of some of the destinations they need to get to every day.” Compact development allows there to be interconnectedness within urban areas so that people can use the automobile less often. Studies have shown that areas that take on this sort of development are actually quite successful. “Even accounting for income and other socioeconomic differences, residents drove about 25 percent less in the more compact regions.” No, compact development won’t solve all of the issues related to CO2 emissions, but it is a great step in making our processes in large metropolises more sustainable.
            Many have speculated that there are two theoretical perspectives on how to combat the world’s problems, technological sustainability and ecological sustainability. One of these perspectives, technological sustainability, views technical solutions of creating new innovations as the best way to get the necessary resources to continue living on Earth. The other perspective, ecological sustainability, calls for the alteration of human actions. That is, maybe we shouldn’t find new ways of getting resources, but instead try to use less of those resources and live simpler lives. Ideally, it would be best to combine these two perspectives to fix our planet. Combining the theories from these perspectives would be hard, but it isn’t impossible. Using these two different perspectives, one can study the effectiveness of a sustainable process like compact development. That is, one can look at these two different perspectives and in turn compare them to the features of compact development. In my opinion, it seems as if compact development is sort of like a hybrid of these two perspectives.
The components of technological and ecological sustainability are combined within the method known as compact development. I believe that compact development is a hybrid of these two perspectives because this strategy not only calls for the development of new infrastructures (or the alteration of existing infrastructure) within urban areas, but also tries to alter the lifestyles of citizens living in an urban area. The lifestyles of the citizens in the city would be different because the infrastructure of the city would cause them to drive less. Through the innovative implementation of compact development, people would be forced to use public transit or walk. Thus with more and more people either walking or using public transit, the vehicle miles driven in the area would decrease. “With smart growth, most developments would be built to connect seamlessly with the external street network. These developments would fill in vacant lots, replace failing shopping centers, construct transit-oriented neighborhoods, and revitalize older town centers rather than displacing forests or farmland. This would in turn cause people in urban areas to be near important places as well as have a means of transit (other than the automobile) to get to where they need to go.” This strategy of development would in turn change the processes that happen in a city. With compact development people could have "urban lives" without having the automobile be a necessity. With a well-integrated system of compact development, urban residents could travel around different parts of the city by solely relying on mass transit and/or their own two feet. 
              Neither technological sustainability nor ecological sustainability are perfect methods to fix the problems of our world. These two perspectives both have their pros and cons. With that said, to actually modify our processes to be more sustainable it would be ideal to combine these two perspectives. Compact development is one example of a method that combines the innovativeness of technological sustainability with the environmental awareness of ecological sustainability. 

Thursday, September 20, 2012

America’s Loss of Meaningful Places


After World War II, American society was experiencing some drastic changes. From the Baby Boom to the interstate highways, the United States was becoming a different country. Many argue that these changes were for the better, but one has to realize that these events after the war actually altered American cities. After World War II, many “places that were not worth caring about” sprang across the United States, thus causing the landscapes of the country to become dull and uninteresting.
In his presentation, James Kunstler claimed that after World War II many people in the United States seemed to stop caring about their surroundings. Due to this indifference of one’s geography, “places that were not worth caring about” dominated the country. Most of these places still exist and many more have been established since the 1950’s. But one may wonder why did the United States loose its touch with cities and their built environment? To answer these questions, one has to study the historical occurrences of the country, and see how the byproducts of these events altered the United States. Kunstler claimed “A lot of this [the issues in America’s built environment] comes from the fact that the industrial city in America was such a trauma that we developed this tremendous aversion to the whole idea of the city.” The suburbs were an escape from the disgust found in the industrial cities in the late 1800’s, but as we look later in history they didn’t explode in growth until after 1945. It was this era after the war that produced the lack of identity in American places, and it was all thanks to such tools as the automobile.
In 1971, John B. Rae asserted, “Modern suburbia is a creature of the automobile, and it cannot survive without the automobile.” Though this might have been a drastic claim, in the late 1940’s and early 1950’s automobiles did become more accessible to the American general public. This innovation drastically changed the infrastructures and landscapes of the country, “fundamentally restructuring the pattern of everyday life.” With the implementation of the Interstate Highway Act, cars were able to take hold of these pathways towards the outskirts of the city. As Jackson states in his paper, “the interstate system virtually guaranteed that future urban growth would perpetuate a centerless sprawl.” This urban sprawl in turn affected the general public’s opinion on architecture and their sense of place. People were more interested in efficiency, promptness, and instant returns instead of quality and meaningfulness. “As the United States became a rubber-tire civilization, a tasteless, cheap, and forgettable architecture emerged in the suburbs.” As the years went by, more Americans possessed this lack of connection with their surroundings, and lost most (if not all) of their appreciation for a sense of place. Such a mindset in the general public caused there to be a drastic increase in the number of places that weren’t significant to anyone. This in turn created those areas that Kunstler termed “places that are not worth caring about” to spring about.
Even though the United States is dominated by places that people have no connection with, there are still some spaces that are worth caring about. I, myself, have been fond of several places. One of these places is a park that is a mile away from my house. This park is called Norwood Park, and I have been going to this park since I was a child. Not only is it a place where children can play, but it also is an area where people can come relax and enjoy life. Norwood Park is a unifying space that brings people together, and serves as an oasis from the hustle and bustle of city life. I think this park is important because not only does it allow people to engage in a multitude of activities, but it also has a charm to it that draws people. The park is full of life, beauty, and most importantly it allows one to understand the significance of a sense of a place. I would hate to see Norwood Park being destroyed because it has and always will have a special place in my life. 

Tuesday, September 18, 2012

Presentation on Sustainable Planning


On September 18th, I attended a presentation on sustainability. Margaret Cederoth, who is an urban planner at the Parsons Brinckerhoff firm in Sacramento, California, gave the presentation. The presentation was about how cities can be sustainable. It was extremely interesting to hear an actual practicing urban planner talk about her work as well discuss how she implements the elements of sustainable processes into her planning.
One of the most interesting things about the presentation was Ms. Cederoth’s account on Masdar, the carbon-free city in the United Arab Emirates. During the presentation, she discussed how she was part of the team of people who were able to use their skills to create a sustainable city out of a huge empty area. There aren’t that many opportunities for urban planners to build a city from nothing, so it was quite fascinating to hear how this was done. I was also intrigued how Ms. Cederoth described that Masdar was built “with utilities in mind.” In other words, the team of people that worked on this project knew that human beings consume and use a lot of resources. With that in mind, they tried to implement environmentally friendly and efficient ways to collect energy for the city. Examples ranged from solar panels on nearly all of the buildings to a wind tower in the middle of the university. All in all, I was quite fascinated that such a project as a “carbon-free city” could actually be created in the real world.
Many of the topics that Ms. Cederoth discussed were related to the information we have learned from UP 199. Within the presentation, she discussed such phenomena as ecological footprints, the process of conserving and loading as well as many other elements on the foundations of sustainability. For example, Ms. Cederoth touched upon the reason why people in the United Arab Emirates wanted a carbon-free city. She mentioned that the “UAE has one of the highest ecological footprints per person in the world (11.9 global hectares per person).” This statement was directly related to one of our previous lectures where we discussed how there are many countries in the Middle East (these are countries that are extracting oil) have enormous ecological footprints per person. Ms. Cederoth also touched upon the topic of carbon emissions. She discussed how they tried to make the construction company use more sustainable methods in their building. For example, they wanted to limit the usage of cement in the city because “the manufacturing of cement is responsible for about 5% of human-caused emissions of carbon dioxide.” This goes to show that people can build new infrastructures in ways that won’t harm the Earth in the future. Whatever the case, I really enjoyed this presentation and thought it was extremely cool to hear the things we have learned in class being implemented by real urban planners like Margaret Cederoth.


Thursday, September 13, 2012

The Eminent Future of Our Planet Earth


More and more people in the world are driving cars that run on oil. More and more people in the world are using electricity that is created by the burning of coal. These human activities have repercussions (like carbon emissions) that are drastically affecting the state of our planet. Due to these drastic issues, researchers and scientists have been trying to come up with other resources to be used as alternatives to fossil fuels.
So as to halt the problems of global warming, greenhouse effects, and other issues, people are calling for the transition away from fossil fuels. Some are calling for the usage of ethanol instead of oil. While others claim that windmills and solar panels are the future gateways for storing energy. With all of these alternative ideas, there are many others who are skeptical about the transition away from fossil fuels. In his article “21st Century Energy: Some Sobering Thoughts,” Vaclav Smil explains that given our rates of consumption it is going to be extremely difficult for this transition to happen. Even though Smil does have some interesting points, there is a bit of a flaw in his argument. Smil argues that given our current capabilities and the existing insatiable appetites of the world’s people, it is going to be hard to use new alternative energy sources. In other words, Smil believes in “technological sustainability,” and that the only way for people to progress is for them to change the methods by which they obtain resources. He says, “Other renewable energy flows (like those from windmills and solar panels) could not cover today’s worldwide total primary energy supply.” In other words, Smil believes that the lifestyles of humans should not be altered/changed. Instead, new innovations need to be created to allow for our ways of life to continue as they are.
As evidenced in his article, Vaclav Smil is extremely pessimistic about humanity’s ability to transition away from fossil fuels. He says that the scale of shift to a new energy source is going to be extremely enormous and difficult. Also, in his article it is stated, “today there is no readily available non-fossil energy source that is large enough to be exploited on the requisite scale.” The existing fossil fuels being used provide a lot more energy that any other alternative energy sources. So, there doesn’t seem to be any alternative energy source that has enough energy to keep up with our lifestyles and rates of consumption. Smil contends that storage issues would arise if human beings were to actually use windmills and solar panels. For example, “because wind and direct solar radiation are intermittent and far from predictable, they could never deliver such high load factors like those of thermal electricity generators.” All in all, Vaclav Smil is not confident about the reliability of using non-fossil fuels as energy sources.
With all of these pessimistic views that Smil presents in his paper, one wonders what our planet will be like if human beings did not “meet” the energy demands. Well, such an image reminds me of something stated in Professor Smith’s lecture. I think that the world would be a devastating and ugly one where countries are having wars over resources with many people dying because they don’t have the sufficient means to survival (i.e. food, water, etc). Such a world would also have many natural disasters like hurricanes and floods happening as a result of global warming. Such a horrid image could be contrasted to what our world would be like if human beings did make a difference to make the Earth a better place. I think such a world would be very communal where people would grow their own food and share it with those in their community. People would hardly ever use cars, and as a result the highway systems would become massive bike trails. This is a bit of a drastic idea, but it is something that could possibly happen if our processes became sustainable. Whatever the case, it is important to be educated about the state of our planet.